this one playsback with mame32 or official mamel with out sound (at least for me in winXP), try that (-nosound or -soundcard 0 for dosmame), it should be ok.
Strange, I get the same playback with sound off. Win58, right? It's not a desync issue since there are two players... would this happen for some reason other than the guy pressed 5,5,1,2?
yeah win58 or mame58 works for me. maybe try deleting the nvram? but i think there is no nvram created for this game... and i just played it back WITH sound when using win98 and mame3258.